28
Jun 13

Friday Poll Special – The Great Britpop Sorting Hat!

FT • 7,656 views

We are now firmly into the BRITPOP YEARS on Popular, oh yes, so it’s time to consider its musical legacy in the only language we truly understand, viz. a ticky-box poll.

We have selected 32 bands who someone, somewhere, might possibly have once described as Britpop. Tick all the ones you like and by science we will be able to finally, once and for all, define terms like “Britpop D-List” and “second divison Britpop”. Isn’t that a noble endeavour? I thought so.

Which of these Britpop bands were Any Good At All?

  • Pulp 70%
  • Blur 64%
  • Kenickie 53%
  • Suede 52%
  • Supergrass 48%
  • Elastica 47%
  • Super Furry Animals 44%
  • Ash 43%
  • The Divine Comedy 39%
  • Oasis 35%
  • Boo Radleys 30%
  • Lush 30%
  • Bluetones 28%
  • Catatonia 25%
  • Mansun 24%
  • Sleeper 24%
  • Black Grape 23%
  • Lightning Seeds 21%
  • Gene 21%
  • Longpigs 19%
  • Echobelly 18%
  • Shed Seven 16%
  • Space 14%
  • Ocean Colour Scene 14%
  • WELLER 14%
  • Kula Shaker 13%
  • Cast 11%
  • Menswear 11%
  • My Life Story 11%
  • Marion 8%
  • Seahorses 8%
  • Northern Uproar 3%

Total Voters: 1,496

Poll closes: No Expiry

Loading ... Loading ...

Comments

1 6 7 8 All
  1. 176
    23 Daves on 3 Jul 2013 #

    I love “Coming Up” as well, and I think it and “Dog Man Star” excellently showcased two different sides of the band’s personality, although I’m sure “Coming Up” didn’t have that concept behind it and was probably just intended to put them back in the commercial game. It’s just a shame that most of the rest of their output feels so inessential (half of “Suede” is great, but it sounds far patchier than a lot of people seem to give it credit for).

    Still, two fantastic albums in one career is a much better tally than most bands manage.

  2. 177
    Rory on 3 Jul 2013 #

    For me it fits here: Coming Up > Dog Man Star > Bloodsports > everything else.

  3. 178
    swanstep on 4 Jul 2013 #

    Heh, the discussion of Kenickie here has introduced me to a new word ‘mackem’. Its Urban Dictionary definitions are hilarious.

  4. 179
    Ed on 4 Jul 2013 #

    #168 “Noel G always used to acknowledge Nirvana’s influence on Oasis….”

    I’d never heard that. It’s a great fact. Heraclitus would have loved it:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unity_of_opposites

  5. 180
    The Riverboat Captain on 4 Jul 2013 #

    Wot, no Manics?

  6. 181
    Tom on 5 Jul 2013 #

    I’m going to close this poll today when I put the next entry up, btw.

    Unless I don’t put the next entry up. But I will dammit.

  7. 182
    fivelongdays on 5 Jul 2013 #

    Hmm…the fact that Tom has hinted the next entry is going to long indicates it could well be in for a beasting! Interesting…

  8. 183
    weej on 5 Jul 2013 #

    Will we still be able to post comments? Britpop nuggets is imminent!

  9. 184
    Tom on 5 Jul 2013 #

    Oh totally – the thread remains! I’m just going to stop the voting, since we’ve already reached 3x the voters of any previous Freaky Trigger poll! Do you want to run Britpop Nuggets as a separate post, Weej?

  10. 185
    fivelongdays on 5 Jul 2013 #

    IMHO Britpop Nuggets ought to be a post on its own – I for onwle don’t want it to be subsumed at the bottom of a thread.

  11. 186
    weej on 5 Jul 2013 #

    Well, certainly I would, yes. How would I go about doing that? ETA is Monday morning.

  12. 187
    Tom on 5 Jul 2013 #

    Drop freakytrigger@gmail.com an email and we can sort something out!

  13. 188
    Patrick Mexico on 7 Jul 2013 #

    Always thought it was quite funny, but bizarre, that Richard Oakes, 17, was uprooted from school to join Suede.

    I’m trying to imagine the media reaction had they used exactly the same recruitment strategy with a female member.

  14. 189
    Izzy on 7 Jul 2013 #

    It was a pretty great move, if only because nobody else had ever dreamed of it (Mick Taylor definitely not the same thing). It would’ve been awful if they’d just got some session bloke.

  15. 190
    Tom on 7 Jul 2013 #

    I was working in the Music & Video Exchange Book And Comic Exchange just after Suede recruited Neil Codling (around the same time as Oakes). Codling came in one afternoon shortly after, I recognised him from the Melody Maker, and watched with interest as he blitzed our ‘cult books’ section, arriving at the counter with a foot-high pile of paperbacks by Kerouac, Burroughs, Bukowski, Hunter S Thompson, and others. He had a surprisingly gloomy look on his face. I have assumed to this day that Brett Anderson had presented him with a drug culture reading list.

  16. 191
    Izzy on 7 Jul 2013 #

    Hahaha. Brett lived just round the corner too, it all checks out.

    I wonder how Richard’s parents reacted to their son’s sixth-form project? He seems like a level-headed sort, but there’s many a seventeen-year-old wouldn’t've survived long being dropped into peak Suede.

  17. 192
    a tanned rested and unlogged lørd sükråt wötsît on 7 Jul 2013 #

    Hang on, this never-before-dreamt-of strategy (especially using schoolgirls) is EXACTLY how Susanne and Joanne were recruited into the Human League — spotted by Phil Oakey at a Sheffield disco dancing (poss.round handbags), while still schoolgirls doing their A-levels.

  18. 193
    a tanned rested and unlogged lørd sükråt wötsît on 7 Jul 2013 #

    And Michael Schenker was I think only 15 when he traded up from support group (the Scorpions, as led by his brother) to lead guitar in UFO — though I suppose that’s more Mick Taylorish, in that he was already touring Germany in a metal band, and hence I guess not in school any more really.

  19. 194
    a tanned rested and unlogged lørd sükråt wötsît on 7 Jul 2013 #

    So in short Eater >> Suede

  20. 195
    admin on 12 Jul 2013 #

    Worth marking here that Kenickie have had mixed fortunes on FT

    http://freakytrigger.co.uk/ft/2008/10/not-the-freaky-trigger-top-100-tracks-of-all-time-no-38/

  21. 196
    Patrick Mexico on 12 Jul 2013 #

    I was delighted to be tweeted by Menswear’s Johnny Dean himself this week.. (though perhaps I was being condescending, so to atone, I bought Nuisance from Amazon for, er, £1.27. Genuinely can’t wait – always thought Daydreamer was a masterpiece of cocky, minimalist punk-pop. Strangely, used to think it was Billy Idol.)

    https://twitter.com/Sully_vs_Sully/status/354702303493763072

  22. 197
    Tom on 13 Jul 2013 #

    I’ve closed the poll now, well done the new official “Big Three” of Britpop: Pulp, Blur and Kenickie. Bad luck the Uproar BUT! their moment will come as they feature on Weej’s BRITPOP NUGGETS which will hopefully be up this weekend.

  23. 198
    Patrick Mexico on 4 Aug 2013 #

    Many would put The Charlatans in the “Madchester” box but One To Another was possibly my favourite Britpop song. A fearless, cathartic response to the tragic death of Rob Collins… so much of a brick shithouse of an anthem even “Be your Spiderwoman, I’ll be your Spiderman” was something you could laugh with, rather than at. Though the intro does sound like the “Such and such a body’s [colours of team] army” chant and a tiny bit uncomfortable with anything hinting at the blanket football, “birds” and boozing obsession – the lack of anyone (apart from Pulp and Welsh Bunnies YET AGAIN!) to comment sagely on how it might be slightly fucking things up ensured Britpop was never much fun again after c. September 1996.

  24. 199
    Patrick Mexico on 4 Aug 2013 #

    A slightly embargoed MSBWT record, but on 8/9/96 the #2 to One to Another’s #3 was just as great – Kula Shaker’s Hey Dude. No flaming swastikas (Hindu or Hitler), no dubious politics, not much “just butthurt as I was 30 years too late for the Beatles meeting Ravi Shankar!” Just great, infectious Madchester. With images of tombstones, IMAGES OF TOMBSTONES. Unfortunately, they were held off number 1 by a certain girl group hell-bent on ruining the fine art of stream-of-consciousness lyrics.. that debut hit also brought the curtain down on Britpop’s imperial phase. But more – maybe excessively – on them later.

  25. 200
    23 Daves on 5 Aug 2013 #

    Has anyone noticed this review of Northern Uproar’s latest album on The Quietus yet? http://thequietus.com/articles/12942-northern-uproar-all-that-was-has-gone-review

    Somebody still loves them, obviously. I’m speechless.

  26. 201
    Ed on 7 Aug 2013 #

    @200 – Now that is impressive. Hard to imagine a sharper hipster move in 2013 than being a massive Northern Uproar fan.

  27. 202
    Patrick Mexico on 12 Aug 2013 #

    I just listened to Monday Morning by the Candyskins on Spotify. It’s quite possibly the worst song ever recorded.

  28. 203
    swanstep on 13 Aug 2013 #

    @202, Patrick. MM’s not *that* bad! A little dull, yes, but worse than even the worst thing in just the current charts? I don’t think so. That said, I’ve always slightly resented The Candyskins their ordinariness, since I’ve always assumed they took their name from this classic from The Fire Engines (who were essential listening if you were of a certain age).

  29. 204
    Cumbrian on 13 Aug 2013 #

    Goodbye to Jon Brookes – drummer for The Charlatans. Long term battle with a brain tumour apparently.

    Not Britpop according to this thread (and probably were Madchester/baggy holdovers), but mentioned in this thread, so I’ll file it here.

  30. 205
    Patrick Mexico on 13 Aug 2013 #

    Re 203: Well, do not underestimate the power of postwhoring! (And girls with plaits and very strange heads.)

    Hardly the most original thing I’ll ever post, but the Best Song Ever is a strong contender for the worst song ever.

  31. 206
    Patrick Mexico on 13 Aug 2013 #

    Re 204 – on a serious note: yes, terrible news. And to think only a few days back, on this very page, I was celebrating the fact he was talismanic in one of my favourite pieces of music. RIP.

  32. 207

    […] pop culture website, Freaky Trigger, published a poll about Britpop bands yesterday, which got me thinking about the genre and its cover […]

  33. 208
    Alan not logged in on 10 Apr 2014 #

    For more of your Britpop polling requirements there’s 6music http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p01tmt65

    Do you think we should adopt a polling “code of conduct” or T&C? (No, we should not – or we’ll end up with members of Kenickie NOT tweeting links)

  34. 209
    Tom on 10 Apr 2014 #

    I am a member of the Market Research Society so our polls are naturally guaranteed to operate to the highest professional standards.

1 6 7 8 All

Add your comment

(Register to guarantee your comments don't get marked as spam.)


Required

Required (Your email address will not be published)

Top of page