29
Apr 09

Raspberry Berate

FT + Proven By Science1 comment • 146 views

An interesting blog post about the recent discovery that our galaxy “smells of raspberries” (and rum, though whether man rum or lady rum is unspecified).

The blog asks: given the irrelevance of that ‘fact’ to astronomy, should it have been reported? The German astronomers are quick to distance themselves from the raspberry herring: but if the angle doesn’t obscure the story (galaxy contains very complex molecules), then where’s the harm? The people who only take away the raspberry factoid probably wouldn’t have encountered – or absorbed much of – a drier, flavour-free story. They’re the informational equivalent of the people who download a track illegally which they would never have bought anyway: any loss they’ve caused is purely rhetorical.

Comments

  1. 1
    David Bradley on 29 Apr 2009 #

    Interesting follow up point Tom. Slightly rum do though as I think there’s a world of difference between lay people who would read a space news story and those who’d be interested in the chemistry angle per se. I certainly don’t think they shouldn’t have reported the story in the Guardian and Ian Sample is, I’m sure, well aware of having blown a raspberry at the science in some sense…

Add your comment

(Register to guarantee your comments don't get marked as spam.)


Required

Required (Your email address will not be published)

Top of page