Sep 12


Popular41 comments • 3,851 views

#700, 8th January 1994

Looking back on the Summer of Ragga (and indeed the Winter Of Ragga), what strikes me is how cuddly its chart presence was. Dancehall was a controversial import: for a pop audience used to reggae as good vibes unity music, the arrival of young lions like Shabba Ranks was a shock. Particularly as the sex, swagger and silk trousers might be mixed up inextricably with vicious homophobia. But none of that drama showed up in the charts. While The Word took time out from dousing students in beans to grapple with the issues, pre-watershed ragga was a brighter, sunnier experience.

Chaka Demus – the rough one – and Pliers – the smooth one – thoroughly retool a pop standard but it’s hard to imagine anyone being annoyed (or thrilled) by the resulting jollities: “Twist And Shout” is the kind of song which is so often covered you’d think it can’t have purists anymore. It has survived dozens of styles and, for that matter, will endure its current life in reality show limbo.

This particular version is all twist and very little shout – cheerful, almost languid, cantering along without any real spark but entertaining all the same. Musically it’s not taking many risks – there’s a lascivious intro from richer-voiced guest Jack Radics, a nagging backing yelp that sounds like a persistent terrier locked in the studio, and a twangy arrangement positioning the track as an “Oh Carolina” style blend of old and new. Pliers cajoles, his voice fluttering around Chaka Demus gruffer commands, but both men are more memorable elsewhere and their performance is a microcosm of the track: nobody does anything wrong, and somehow it fails to stick anyway.

(For those still intrigued by the idiosyncracies of Popular’s marking system, this was on the absolute 5/6 cusp until I listened to it with the sun out.)



1 2 All
  1. 31
    Tom on 21 Sep 2012 #

    #29 Rotterdam Termination Source – “Poing” would be the record in question Rosie!

  2. 32
    flahr on 21 Sep 2012 #

    This would be so much better if they had Flashie going “get higher baby” over the “aaaaah”s (5)

  3. 33
    Mark G on 21 Sep 2012 #

    #29, quite: I see they also had a hit with a song called “I wanna be your man”, so hmmm…

  4. 34
    weej on 21 Sep 2012 #

    ‘Poing’ is a landmark record, sure. I’d hesitate to use any positive adjectives, as it’s as objectively terrible as music gets, but you have to sort-of-admire how relentless and pointless it is.

  5. 35
    flahr on 21 Sep 2012 #

    “Poing” = (8)

  6. 36
    Billy Smart on 8 Oct 2012 #

    TOTPWatch. Chaka Demus & Pliers performed ‘Twist and Shout’ on Top of the Pops on 16 December 1993. Also in the studio that week were; East 17 and Take That, plus two live performances via satellite from Diana Ross in Paris and Haddaway from Disneyworld, Florida. Tony Dortie was the host.

  7. 37
    Erithian on 11 Jan 2013 #

    Rory all the way up at #5 had it about right – I’ve just watched the video in the early days of January on the coldest night in a while, and it does you good. Tuneful, fun, everyone’s having a ball, no-one’s getting dissed, and although there’s no great merit to the re-working, I’m sure the Isley Brothers wouldn’t mind – and you’d want to hit the dancefloor for it too.

    Oh, those TOTP hosts of the anti-personality era – did they ever get to be even recognised in the street? No? Their own homes?…

  8. 38
    Patrick Mexico on 26 Mar 2013 #

    Don’t mind this, and today’s weather probably isn’t the most appropriate environment – but can’t give it any more than a 5. Why? Because the backing track sounds like someone doing the midnight boogaloo with a squirrel.

  9. 39
    Lee Saunders on 6 Jan 2018 #

    I love how three #1 singles (Let’s Dance, the Masses Against the Classes and Can We Fix It?) all borrow the Twist and Shout intro, but when Twist and Shout finally gets to #1 itself, that intro is nowhere to be found at the start (it does crop up mid-way through IIRC).

  10. 40
    Andrew Farrell on 30 Jan 2018 #

    In fairness, it’s not the intro to the Beatles’ version either…

  11. 41
    Gareth Parker on 20 May 2021 #

    Pleasant enough in my opinion. 5/10.

1 2 All

Add your comment

(Register to guarantee your comments don't get marked as spam.)

If this was number 1 when you were born paste [stork-boy] or [stork-girl] into the start of your comment :)


Required (Your email address will not be published)

Top of page