25
Feb 10

FERRY AID – “Let It Be”

FT + Popular60 comments • 4,550 views

#588, 4th April 1987, video

A newspaper is a version of the world, and a successful newspaper builds a world that not only reflects the real one, it infects it. In its 80s heyday The Sun was not only the highest circulation daily paper in Britain, it had a cultural weight that went well beyond that: it comforted its readers and haunted its enemies in the way the Mail does now. The Sun’s mix of tub-thumping, scandal, sex, games and coupons might have simply been a variation on a winning tabloid formula that stretched back to the Boer War, but editor Kelvin McKenzie pitched the paper exactly right for its brash, greedy times.

“Let It Be” is The Sun’s number one record, its logo proudly on the label and the sleeve. The disaster which sparked the single – a car ferry capsized due to crew negligence, killing 193 people – might not ordinarily have led to a charity record, but several of the dead were Sun readers, on board the Herald Of Free Enterprise because the paper had run a special offer on ferry tickets, away-day breaks to Europe being a reliable sales booster. So the Sun owned the event from start to finish, acting as chief mourner. After the disaster it hit on Stock Aitken and Waterman to produce the record and started working its, and their pop contacts book. Within a week this is what they’d come up with.

“Let It Be” itself is – like “Everybody Hurts” – one of those songs which was doomed to be a charity record sooner or later. I’ve never really enjoyed it – for all its obvious sincerity it feels too generalised and woolly for me to find it a source of comfort, and without that sentimental connection the hymnal pace is a chore. But simplicity and honesty have always suited McCartney well and it’s certainly not a song I’d sneer at. Also, its very solidity makes it – on paper – a good frame for a record that’s going to use a lot of voices.

Even so the Ferry Aid “Let It Be” is a discombobulating listen. For a start, in commercial and stylistic terms the talent is more than usually mismatched. But charity records always have their lesser contributors, and things like Paul King’s inability to sing the word “be” are all part of the experience. A bigger problem is that the music won’t get out of the way – the kind of stateliness “Let It Be” needs is completely alien to SAW, who garnish the record with bibbling keyboards, horrid synth tones, a chuntering mid-paced beat, and that’s even before you get to the Knopfler and Gary Moore guitar solos: the ‘something for everyone’ ethos of the charity record line up taken to an extreme. The uncomfortable thought that comes to mind hearing SAW’s backing, though, is that this is pretty much the type of thing those ill-fated passengers would have heard had the ferry sailed and they’d wandered into the cocktail lounge to hear the on-board entertainment.

At least until the ending, anyway. Kate Bush does her line, in the deep register she’d just used on “Don’t Give Up”, and it’s a revelation: her warm, sad, cocooning voice suits the song and the occasion absolutely. There are a few seconds near-silence after that, as if everybody else is suddenly thinking “Oh shit, this could actually have been good.” And then the moment passes and it’s time for the mass chant, and for the single to finish on a note of laughter, high-fiving and applause. Because that’s what charity records and newspaper campaigns are all about: happy endings. It’s The Sun wot Number One it.

2

Comments

1 2 3 All
  1. 51
    CarsmileSteve on 28 Feb 2010 #

    wow, i see su pollard and several members of the grange hill cast in that singalong bit at the end as well…

  2. 52
    CarsmileSteve on 28 Feb 2010 #

    oh and bonnie tyler!

  3. 53
    Erithian on 1 Mar 2010 #

    So, the people whose only Number 1 glory came as a result of this song were… Nick Kamen, Paul King, Mark King, Taffy, Jaki Graham, Gary Moore, Mark Knopfler, Nik Kershaw, Edwin Starr, Curiosity, Ruby Turner, Hazel O’Connor, The Nolans, Steve Strange, Su Pollard, Mandy Smith, Maxi Priest, Go West, The Alarm and, er, Simon Bates. Plus the still-delectable Linda Lusardi and various other Page Three girls. (Eat your heart out Katie Price.) Any others I’ve missed?

  4. 54
    Billy Smart on 1 Mar 2010 #

    The Alarm!? Steve Strange!? With every new comment, I discover yet more pop personalities hidden in the fabric of this dismal single…

  5. 55
    MikeMCSG on 1 Mar 2010 #

    #53 Ian, a couple of minor corrections to the list. The Nolans were also (and more prominently) on The Crowd’s “You’ll Never Walk Alone” and Nik Kershaw wrote a nineties number one. I think possibly Mark King played on Midge Ure’s “If I Was” but don’t take that as gospel.
    Also Steve Strange famously appeared in the “Ashes To Ashes” video but that might be stretching a point !

  6. 56
    Rory on 9 Mar 2010 #

    Coming to this cold, it doesn’t sound quite as objectionable to me as most of you find it, but it’s still quite objectionable. 3, including a bonus mark for Kate Bush’s interlude.

    If they were going for maximum inappropriateness, they should have covered “Here Comes the Sun”. Or something by the Doors.

  7. 57
    taDOW on 4 Dec 2010 #

    obligatory/amazing – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8cNHCP3juQ&feature=player_embedded

  8. 58
    lonepilgrim on 4 Dec 2010 #

    re 57 that’s like a vision of purgatory where the botoxed hordes of daytime TV are condemned to sing for eternity

  9. 59
    Rory on 6 Feb 2011 #

    RIP Gary Moore, whose only Popular appearance was here. I was listening to my favourite Thin Lizzy album, Black Rose: A Rock Legend, just this morning – he deserves to be remembered for the likes of that rather than this.

  10. 60
    Erithian on 7 Feb 2011 #

    Did anyone catch Bob Geldof paying tribute to Gary Moore on Radio 5 this morning? Talking about blues musicians, the day Clapton played on one of Geldof’s songs and the thrill of watching him feel his way instantly into a track he’d never heard before; then about the Irish connection to the blues which inspired Moore, Rory Gallagher and Van Morrison. Nicky Campbell was listening enraptured until Geldof, suddenly aware of his lyrical flights of fancy, said “Sorry if I’m sounding a bit of a twat here…” Cue hurried presenter’s apology.

    RIP Gary too – “Parisienne Walkways” one of my favourite singles of the 70s.

1 2 3 All

Add your comment

(Register to guarantee your comments don't get marked as spam.)


If this was number 1 when you were born paste [stork-boy] or [stork-girl] into the start of your comment :)

Required

Required (Your email address will not be published)

Top of page