The Freaky Trigger Top 100 Tracks Of All Time No. 41. t.a.T.u. - Not Gonna Get Us
There is a strange double headed hydra lurking at the centre of pop marketing. The first head is the music. The music is the product, and the music is what people are buying. If the music is good enough, surely there is no need for extraneous marketing. However the second head rears up here, and will happily point out the huge number of other singles being released all of which have some claim to being good. Since once you are inside the belly of the beast (in this case a hydra) it becomes more difficult to spot those sure fire winners. Especially if those future hits require a couple of plays. So how do you get a couple of plays? Sensationalist marketing. Such as:
LIPSTICK LESBIAN RUSSIAN TEEN POP SENSATIONS TATU FOLLOW UP SINGLE SMASH
SHOCKING VIDEO FOR SAPPHIC SENSATIONS WHO WOULD NOT BE LEGAL IN THE UK
TREVOR HORN PRODUCES NOT QUITE AS GOOD FOLLOW UP SINGLE TO ALL THE THINGS SHE SAID
Yes, one of these headlines is not like the other. Because there is little room for truth in marketing, and as t.a.T.u.’s second big world hit is still a pretty good single. Not Gonna Get Us relies strongly on the girls strangled cat vocals, which are still startling. It reminds you of All the Things She Said, without completely replicating it - and in its own way continues the loose story of the previous track. It is Lena and Yulia’s forbidden love against the world, and the world is not going to get them. Not that their plan of “hiding in plain sight making a lot of noise” makes an awful lot of sense. But it works as a robust dancefloor filler, happy to fit in a pop, goth or emo club (where we might find our confused teens punching the air shouting “They Don’t Understand Us”.)
I suppose my question is - bearing in mind that this list was made in 2004 - does Not Gonna Get Us stand up as a great single now? If we remove it from its trucking video, from the lesbian chic and the tabloid hoo-hah about nothing. Lesbianism has always been a strange hetero male fetish, and clearly one played up to the hilt at this point of global domination. Can the song also be separated from revelations of non-lesbianism, childbirth and that piss-poor petulant Eurovision song contest entry? Truth is it can’t be divorced from either, and much like the less impressive follow up records of many a big thing, when revisited later its difficult to recreate the excitement, the feeling of NOW that allows a track like this to go to number one.
Of course, the comments box will now be filled with people saying how much they prefer Not Gonna Get Us. GO BACK TO YOUR MY MORNING JACKET ALBUMS!
That video, rimmed in tell tale FT pink! (Fixed)
Site powered by
Mark G on July 10th, 2008
“We’re sorry, this video is no longer available”
FT's Pete Baran on July 10th, 2008
OK, video fixed. (Its due to the clever new system that Alan has put in that I managed to embed an unembedable video player!)
Anyway, you can enjoy the two long distance Clara’s in full force!
jeff w on July 10th, 2008
Can the song also be separated from … that piss-poor petulant Eurovision song contest entry?
No cos the latter’s on the B-side! Arf. (Well, it is on my copy of the single any road.)
Tom on July 10th, 2008
SCOOBY ALERT! The Eurovision performance is dreadful but the Eurovision song is still my favourite TaTu thing.
a logged-out pˆnk s lord whatnot on July 10th, 2008
tatu were the first “manufactured” group since frankie GtH to look and sound as if they might pull off dramatising — in song and concept-alb form, as well as in production style — the svengali dynamic: just two wild girls on the run from the Evil Devices of their Manager (where said Devices entirely create the focus and force of the story of this flight)
u&k: svengalian is an anagram of VEGAS LENIN (nearly)
FT's vinylscot on July 13th, 2008
I always preferred the performance at the MTV Awards - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QbJ6UAk8Bp8 There’s a brilliant image at around 1:04 where you can see that, manufactured or not, they are quite enjoying themselves. It’s a pity they couldn’t maintain the quality in these two singles.
Also, is this the first TaTu thread anywhere which has got as far as comment @6 without mentioning the Smiths’ cover??